Another Photo Comparison

[darkerhorse]

Recall, SP was born in 1874. So, he would have been 45 in 1919, 48 in 1922, and 50 in 1924, the period when the younger photo was likely taken based on the son-in-law's apparent age.

[MarcuccioV]

Recall, SP was born in 1874. So, he would have been 45 in 1919, 48 in 1922, and 50 in 1924, the period when the younger photo was likely taken based on the son-in-law's apparent age.

I stand by my conclusions.

[darkerhorse]

I know you've made your "final answer". And it's viable. I wonder if anyone else will weigh in.

[darkerhorse]

This is the only other photo I can find of SP.

SP - with grandchildren.jpg

It was likely taken in between the other two photos, but his mustache looks white so it's probably closer to the later photo (1936).

Can you enhance it for comparison?

[MarcuccioV]

Cleaned it up a little...

[darkerhorse]

Okay.

[darkerhorse]

Is the second man from the left in this new photo SP? His son-in-law is on the far right. The difference in their ages is 21 years.

I think he resembles SP (except his left eye looks odd), but I wonder about a 21-year age difference between the two in this photo.

New.jpg

[darkerhorse]

Does colorization of this photo match the others? I'm especially wondering if his hair would have the reddish tone.

Note the ears are clearly visible.

[darkerhorse]

I also learned that SP and his son-in-law did, in fact, belong to the same social club, the one that most of their relatives belonged to.

[darkerhorse]

Is this a better photo?

4 Group.png

[darkerhorse]

Does anyone think there could be a 21-year age difference between them?

[MarcuccioV]

Does anyone think there could be a 21-year age difference between them?

I do not believe this to be SP. This man has a "lazy eye", as you can see. His ears are also concave, like the previous relative comparison you shared. Too many differences in the features.

I'm not sure the colorization helped much.

I also believe these two are MUCH closer in age...

[darkerhorse]

Thanks for your reply.

Siamo d'accordo.