Kaylie, You may want to look at some of the other ports of entry. There are generally some records available for free on ancestry.com, and they have a lot of the manifests for Boston, New Orleans, etc, and border crossings from/to Cananda.

Stato delle Anime 1826-1947 Index in front to Img 49 1830 @ Img 300
Alberi genealogici 1573-1910 Index in front

Good Luck in your search, and if you have any questions, you may contact me at
shirbyrae at aol dot com

Morti/Deaths
These are alphabetized by decedent's First name. But, in the case of women, it may follow with their maiden name or, if they were widowed, by their husband's surname. So, check all possibilities. They may also be shown with their father/parents, as in the case of children. Beware of 2nd ...

Matrimoni/Marriage
These are alphabetized by Groom's First name.
1579-1686 Index in front
1687-1702 Newer Index in front, and @ Img 104 are orig records from 15-1600s Marriages
For reference, Img 156 is the beginning of Sept 1641
1702-1713 Index in front
1713-1719 No index
1719-1746 Index in ...

Battesimi/Baptisms
These are generally alphabetized by the father's First name. Father and mother, then child, then page.
There are a couple of books that decided to experiment? with turning some of the entries around, (child, then father, mother, page), but they are few.

1566-1617 This has a new ...

San Giorgio Martire Catholic Church Records, Prizzi, Palermo Province, Sicily located at

https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.3.1/TH-1-159314-64601-86?c...

THESE RECORDS ARE IN LATIN, VERY, VERY FEW ARE IN ITALIAN!

For example:
Giuseppe is, therefore, Joseph/Josephi/Josephus and since there are no ...

Hi, Kaylie,
I found your Giuseppe Petralia on the Family Search site in the records of Monreale Diocese for Prizzi:
https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.3.1/TH-1-159314-64849-56?cc=2046915&wc=MMRN-SGQ:683635291
That should take you to the page of the entry of his baptism dated 23 Feb 1903, on pg 76 img ...