TerraLavoro wrote:My best estimate is 1860-1870, so late 1860s say.
You say the manifest is on Ancestry.
I did a search of all Canadian arrivals for Agostina/o Carnevale (in fact, all Carnevale) and this is the only one that appears.
However, I did find an Antonio Carnevale, born about 1872, arriving Montreal in 1902
Name: Antonio Carnevale
Gender: Male
Age: 30
Birth Year: abt 1872
Date of Arrival: 31 Jul 1902
Vessel: Lake Ontario
Search Ship Database: Search for the Lake Ontario in the 'Passenger Ships and Images' database
Port of Arrival: Quebec and Montreal, Quebec, Canada
Port of Departure: Liverpool, England
I will take another look.
EDIT TO ADD:
Possibly the death record you are searching for?
He looks to be age 55 at his death in 1903.
That would put a birth year of 1848...
Name: Agostino Carnevale
Event: Enterrement (Burial)
Burial Year: 1903
Burial Location: Montréal, Québec (Quebec)
Place of Worship or Institution: Basilique Notre-Dame
Right side, third entry
T.