Unfortunately, not everyone was counted in the earlier censuses.
I found Benjamin Fariolia in the 1840 census also. (That is the right one.)
In the 1820 New York City Directory by William A. Mercer I found
"Farriolus, Benj. - art. flowers - 53 Division" that is probably a Latinized version of his name since anything Latin was **SPAM** in 1820.
I have not gotten back to the Library yet to find more.
Sonata 24
Maybe he will show up in the voting register?
Thank you for all of your help.
Benjamino FARIOLI from Italy to New York City in 1796?
Re: Benjamino FARIOLI from Italy to New York City in 1796?
Part Italian, all New Yorker.