In any case, I'm going to go ahead and submit it and cross my fingers! My Mom filled out the Registration of Vital Records form and I'm waiting on my Birth Certificate to be translated.
Of course I just came across a speed bump in this whole process. I was double checking everything against the information posted on the website when I noticed it states a copy of my parent's marriage certificate needs to be submitted. No where on the Registration of Vital Records Form does it say that it's needed.
My mom dug up her atto di matrimonio and it's in tatters. Taped up and falling apart. If it survives another bout of photocopying, it'll be a miracle.

I'd like to contact the comune and request another copy. I found an email address for the Anagrafe office. My problem is that my Italian isn't the greatest. Could someone post a form letter I can email? I would REALLY appreciate it.
